Amici Italian Restaurant

The Underhills

Although Amici has been part of Saint Augustine for over two decades, Freddy and Jenn Underhill's dream came true when they purchased Amici in March 2020. However, a week later, they were shut down for dine-in service due to COVID-19. The combination of hard work, determination and amazing community support, kept the restaurant alive during the pandemic!

They are a husband and wife team determined to provide a unique dining experience while using the freshest ingredients and supporting local as much as possible.

Homemade Pasta

Fresh sheets of pasta made on site with high quality semolina and local fresh eggs are used in our lasagna, manicotti and various specials.

Fresh Catch

Weekly Fresh Catch specials are high quality, sourced locally and hand cut by our chefs

Pancetta Candita!

This signature appetizer was inspired by a breakfast in Sausalito and after six months of test kitchens, is finally where it needs to be!

Plan your next event with us!

Amici has multiple locations for your next event! In fact, besides the 150 seat restaurant, Amici also has a banquet hall called The Milano Room. The perfect private space for any event!

Pizza

Amici's pizzeria is completely separate from the main kitchen and one of the first things you see upon entering! With it's Brooklyn style crust and generous toppings, this pizza is the best around!

Contact